by The American Academy of Pediatrics
By Wendy Sue Swanson, M.D., MBE, FAAP
April 14, 2014
It's important to help our children understand the need to give back, provide, share, and act generously. If we (as parents) act generously in front of our children, they will learn how to give more freely.
Children are more generous when others are aware of their actions.
Researchers set up an experiment in which 5-year-olds were tested with their peers under differing circumstances of transparency and differing audiences (ie, if others could see into the container). They set up a sticker machine that in some settings was transparent (the child giving and child receiving could see how many stickers were up for grabs), and other settings in which only the giver of stickers knew how many stickers he could give.
They had children give out stickers in both settings (transparent and opaque), being able to see the recipient or not.
The results were striking: children were consistently generous only when the recipient and audience of the stickers were fully aware of the donation options (4 stickers over 1 sticker, for example). Children were notably ungenerous when the recipient of stickers couldn't see the options whatsoever. Having an audience present (seeing the recipient) and having the number of stickers be transparent affected children's decisions to give.
The researchers wrote,
"One striking aspect of our results is that children were considerably ungenerous in our task. Indeed, children only showed consistently prosocial behavior in our study in the condition when they could see the recipient and their allocations were fully visible; in all other conditions, children were statistically ungenerous, giving the recipient the smaller amount of stickers."
Researchers made the conclusions that children are differentially generous depending on what the recipient knows about how much you are able to give and if people are present to observe giving. Basically, children will be generous when those who are in need know how much they have to give.
It seems when children can obscure their "wealth," they don't give as much away. When their friends are able to see their choices, children will give peers far more.
At a very early age, children are learning how to position themselves socially. Well before they have a handle on the sociology of their networks and what social reputation really means (normally around age 8), they think strategically about giving as a function of how they can gain a reputation with a peer as a generous citizen or pro-social agent when the recipient observes them.
Fostering Generosity at an Early Age
Recognize that children are influenced by how their generosity is observed and understood. Children may often think about giving under the lenses of competition.
It is known that when competitive constructs are present, children are less generous. So are adults. Therefore, we can help young children understand when competition is present and when it isn't. If a soccer game really isn't a tally of total goals, tell children implicitly. Allow them to learn how to pass the ball and share as teammates early and often. When they are set to compete, let that be clear. But allow situations of play and giving not to be about winning too.
Children modify their behavior in response to having an audience. Help children give to others in full view (donations to a school can drive or soup kitchen; delivering meals to families who need support) and in private or anonymously too (dropping off treats or surprises for those in your life with- out signing your name).
Remind children that thank-you notes are lovely but unnecessary to receive. As an adult, I've often heard people complain about not receiving a thank-you note. It's as if the reason to give a gift was to be acknowledged rather than provide something wonderful for another person.
When we give gifts or lend help to others, try to help children remember why—to provide something for another. It really doesn't have to be recognized. When a thank-you card doesn't come, it doesn't make a gift any less valuable or meaningful for those who were lucky enough to receive.